Jessica
Nestled in the middle of Lake Erie, Kelley’s Island is a peaceful and lovely location providing a special mix of historical appeal and natural beauty. Selecting the correct hotel will help your stay be even more pleasant, whether your trip is exciting or leisurely. Ranked from greatest to lowest, this is a list of the 15 best hotels on Kelley’s Island, ranging from opulent resorts to little bed & breakfasts, so you may choose the ideal location to relax and explore the island.
1. The Inn on Kelley’s Island
Price Range: $ $95+ per night
The Inn on Kelley’s Island presents a wonderful, personal experience. The large suites feature private balconies overlooking Lake Erie, therefore offering a breathtaking perspective of the island’s great beauty. Perfect for people looking for peace, the inn has contemporary conveniences and a small, friendly environment.
- Best For: Couples and romantic getaways
- Facilities: Lake views, garden, free Wi-Fi, restaurant
- Booking Tip: Rooms fill quickly in peak season, so booking early is recommended.
2. Kelley’s Island Venture Resort
Price Range: $220+ per night
With spacious rooms, an outdoor pool, and fantastic views, Kelleys Island Venture Resort is one of the top options for families and couples alike. The resort’s private beach and proximity to local attractions make it a favorite choice for visitors to the island.
- Best For: Families and large groups
- Facilities: Pool, private beach, restaurant, pet-friendly
- Booking Tip: Reserve early to ensure the best views and room options.
3. Red Fern Inn at Rocky Point Winery
Price Range: $210+ per night
Nestled close to Rocky Point Winery, this little bed & breakfast provides a tranquil stay with a bit of local flair. Perfect for a peaceful vacation, guests may take in vineyard views, private rooms, and laid-back environment.
- Best For: Wine lovers and those seeking a quiet getaway
- Facilities: Vineyard views, free breakfast, outdoor patio
- Booking Tip: Enjoy wine tasting sessions included with your stay
4. Bodee’s Bungalow Boutique Hotel
Price Range: $200+ per night
Comfortable, large rooms and modern décor abound in the fashionable Bodee Boutique Hotel. Situated close to the downtown of the island, it provides convenient access to nearby businesses and stores as well as leisure.
- Best For: Couples and boutique hotel lovers
- Facilities: Stylish décor, free Wi-Fi, boutique vibe
- Booking Tip: This hotel is perfect for those who appreciate contemporary design and local charm.
5. Islander Inn Resort
Price Range: $180+ per night
The Islander Inn Resort combines comfort with an island feel. Offering spacious rooms and a laid-back atmosphere, this hotel is known for its friendly service and relaxed vibe, making it a great choice for those looking to experience the island’s natural beauty.
- Best For: Budget-conscious families and couples
- Facilities: Pool, BBQ area, pet-friendly
- Booking Tip: Rooms with views of the lake are especially popular, so book early
6. Harriet’s House
Price Range: $170+ per night
A quaint guesthouse that combines homey charm with great hospitality, Harriet’s House is a fantastic choice for those looking to experience Kelley’s Island like a local. The innkeeper, Harriet, ensures that all guests feel at home in the cozy, well-maintained property.
- Best For: Solo travelers and couples looking for intimacy
- Facilities: Free breakfast, common area for relaxation
- Booking Tip: Ask about the special seasonal packages for discounts
7. Hotel Kilbourne
Price Range: $160+ per night
Located right on the water, Hotel Kilbourne is a historical building that has been transformed into a beautiful boutique hotel. The Victorian charm and stunning views make it a perfect place for a relaxing and romantic stay on the island.
- Best For: History buffs and couples
- Facilities: Victorian architecture, lakefront views, free breakfast
- Booking Tip: Choose a room with a lake view for a memorable experience
8. Put-in-Bay Resort Hotel
Price Range: $150+ per night
This resort hotel is a fantastic choice for visitors to the area, even if it is situated on the neighboring Put-in-Bay Island. The resort has a pool and opulent amenities, but it’s also conveniently close to Put-in-Bay and Kelley’s Island, two nearby attractions.
- Best For: Resort lovers who like variety in their stay
- Facilities: Pool, spa, restaurant, lake access
- Booking Tip: Perfect for those looking to combine Kelley’s Island exploration with nearby attractions.
9. Water’s Edge Retreat
Price Range: $140+ per night
The Water’s Edge Retreat offers private cottages with direct access to the lake. Ideal for those seeking privacy and serenity, this retreat allows guests to enjoy the island’s natural beauty while remaining close to town for dining and shopping.
- Best For: Those seeking seclusion and tranquility
- Facilities: Cottages with lake access, outdoor patio
- Booking Tip: Book early for the best available cottages by the water.
10. South Beach Resort Hotel
Price Range: $130+ per night
A family-friendly resort with beautiful beachfront views, South Beach Resort Hotel offers a variety of room options, from spacious suites to cozy cabins. It’s a great place to relax and take in the scenic views of Lake Erie.
- Best For: Families and beach lovers
- Facilities: Beach access, restaurant, free breakfast
- Booking Tip: Reserve a suite for extra space and comfort.
11. Farrell House Lodge
Price Range: $120+ per night
Located just a short distance from the water, Farrell House Lodge provides a rustic yet comfortable experience. With its picturesque gardens and cozy rooms, this lodge is perfect for nature lovers who enjoy a more laid-back atmosphere.
- Best For: Nature lovers and budget-conscious travelers
- Facilities: Garden area, free Wi-Fi, close to trails
- Booking Tip: The lodge is especially popular during the spring and summer months, so plan accordingly.
12. The Island House Hotel
Price Range: $110+ per night
Perfect for anyone wishing to enjoy the finest of Kelley’s Island without going broke, The Island House Hotel is a lovely and reasonably priced choice. For budget visitors, the hotel provides charming accommodations and a kind atmosphere.
- Best For: Budget-conscious travelers and solo explorers
- Facilities: Free breakfast, cozy rooms
- Booking Tip: The island’s main attractions are within walking distance, making it a great choice for adventurers.
13. Victorian Inn Bed & Breakfast
Price Range: $100+ per night
The Victorian Inn Bed & Breakfast’s quaint, antique-filled rooms and comfortable atmosphere provide a trip back in time. Savor a peaceful stay in a stunning Victorian home that has been refurbished, replete with a customized breakfast and historical accents.
- Best For: Couples and those who enjoy vintage charm
- Facilities: Antique décor, breakfast included, garden
- Booking Tip: The bed and breakfast offers seasonal deals and packages for extended stays.
Final Thoughts
Kelley’s Island has a range of accommodations that cater to all types of travelers. Whether you’re looking for luxury or something more affordable, you’ll find the perfect place to stay with scenic views, great amenities, and welcoming atmospheres. Make sure to book early to secure your spot, especially during peak seasons.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings