If you are anything like me, you crave those sweet summer escapes where time slows down, the breeze carries stories, and life feels simple again. Kelleys Island, Ohio, offers, and believe me, after multiple trips and trying out some of the best Airbnb rentals on the island, I have found gems worth raving about.
Whether you are seeking peace and quiet, lakefront views, or just a cozy place to sip coffee in your pajamas, I have got you covered. These are my handpicked, personally experienced top 10 Airbnb stays on Kelleys Island that combine location, charm, and that just-right vacation magic.
1. The Million Dollar View A‑Frame A Rustic Gem with Front-Row Lake Views
Let’s start with one of my all-time favorites: Danny’s Million Dollar View A‑Frame Cottage. The name isn’t just hype this place literally sits above Lake Erie with panoramic views that make you want to ditch your phone and just stare into the blue. The first time I stayed here, I arrived just before sunset. As I stepped out onto the deck, I was hit with that crisp lake breeze and the sight of fiery orange reflecting off the water. Honestly? That alone was worth the stay.
Inside, it’s full of warm wood tones and cozy cottage vibes. The upstairs loft has a pool table, which made for some fun late-night games after grilling dinner on the patio. If you’re into fishing, you will love that it’s trailer-friendly and just a quick drive from the boat launch.
Why I recommend it:
- Insane lakefront views
- Cozy A-frame design with a vintage feel
- Perfect for couples or small groups
- Firepit and grill for laid-back evenings
- Super host who responds fast
Insider tip: Bring binoculars on clear days, you can spot the mainland and even watch eagles flying overhead.
2. The KI Modern Farmhouse Clean, Chic, and Surprisingly Quiet
This modern Airbnb was a breath of fresh air, literally and figuratively. Tucked away about a mile or so from the ferry docks, the KI Farmhouse is all about clean lines, calm vibes, and easy living. It’s perfect if you want something sleek without sacrificing warmth.
When I stayed here with friends for a girls’ weekend, we instantly fell in love with the open-concept living area and natural light. Mornings started with French press coffee on the deck, and evenings ended around the fire pit with a glass of wine and mosquito candles lit (a must!).
What really stood out? The hosts have stocked it with thoughtful amenities, plenty of kitchen gear, a smart TV, comfy linens, and even local guidebooks. It sleeps around 6, but it doesn’t feel cramped at all.
Why it’s great:
- Stylish and spotless interior
- Private backyard with fire pit and BBQ
- Close to downtown but far enough for peace
- Great for small families or two couples
Insider tip: The island’s general store is just a short bike ride away, so you don’t need to pack tons of groceries.
3. Lakeside Retreat Cottage: Simple Comforts with a Natural Touch
If you like your vacations slow and simple (like, think barefoot mornings and breakfast on the porch), this charming little lakeside cottage might be for you. It’s one of those places that feels like grandma’s lakehouse in the best way possible.
This was my go-to for a solo writing retreat. I needed somewhere quiet and inspiring, and this place delivered. Tucked into a more wooded area, it’s peaceful, shaded, and has a hammock between two old trees that cradled me for hours.
The interior isn’t flashy, but it’s clean and cozy with that nostalgic cabin feel, like stepping back in time. It’s close to some great walking trails, too, which made my morning strolls extra special.
Best features:
- Budget-friendly and cozy
- Steps from nature and wooded trails
- Great porch and outdoor seating
- Peaceful, off-the-grid vibe
Insider tip: The island Wi-Fi can be spotty here, so download anything important before you arrive. But honestly, that digital detox was what I didn’t know I needed.
4. The Beach House at Sunset Point Views, Space, and That Golden Hour Glow
Planning a family trip or gathering with friends? Look no further than this spacious beach house located right at the western tip of the island. This one blew me away not just for the size, but for the energy. It’s lively, airy, and just steps from the water.
We hosted a birthday weekend here, and the layout made it super easy to cook, mingle, and spread out. There’s a large kitchen with bar seating, a massive dining table, and not one but two living areas.
And the sunsets? Unreal. The name Sunset Point says it all. We brought out our beach chairs every night and just sat in awe as the sky turned pink and gold. It’s also close to kayak rentals, so you can launch straight from shore and paddle the evening away.
Why families and groups love it:
- Room for 8-10 guests comfortably
- Multiple decks and balconies
- Modern finishes but very homey
- Water access for swimming or kayaking
Insider tip: Book early, this one gets scooped up fast during summer weekends.
5. The Island Hideaway Pet-Friendly Paradise with a Homey Feel
Now, let’s talk about the dog parents out there (hey, I have been one myself). Not every Airbnb rolls out the welcome mat for pets, but The Island Hideaway does and does it well.
This place felt like a true home. The fenced-in backyard was perfect for my golden retriever to roam freely while I sipped lemonade on the patio. The home had two comfy bedrooms, a fireplace for chilly nights, and an open kitchen where I cooked some of the local walleye we picked up at the dock.
It’s also close to the Glacial Grooves and some of the lesser-known hiking paths perfect for morning walks with your pup. What I really appreciated was the hosts attention to detail: dog bowls, extra towels for muddy paws, and even a bag of treats on the counter when we arrived.
Why it’s a favorite for pet lovers:
- Fully fenced yard
- Clean, cozy, and incredibly welcoming
- Walkable to nature trails
- Thoughtful host amenities
Insider tip: There’s a small dog friendly beach nearby where you can let your pup splash around. Just ask the host for directions they were more than happy to share the local spots.
6. The Captain’s Lakehouse Nautical Charm with Unmatched Water Access
If you have ever dreamed of staying somewhere that feels like a private marina, The Captain’s Lakehouse is as close as it gets. This Airbnb blew me away with its waterfront charm and boat-ready setup. You can literally walk out, step into a kayak, and be gliding across Lake Erie in under five minutes. We booked this home for a little family reunion, and it’s perfect for that kind of getaway.
The place sleeps about 8 comfortably and has a wraparound porch that gave us front-row seats to some of the most vivid sunsets I have ever seen. Every room has these nautical design touches old boat wheels, driftwood art, and lake-themed decor that felt authentic, not cheesy. One of my favorite memories? We grilled freshly caught perch while the kids skipped rocks just steps from the house. It doesn’t get more Lake Erie than that.
Top highlights:
- Walk-out access to private beach and dock
- Spacious layout with beautiful lake decor
- Ideal for boating and fishing enthusiasts
- Super responsive host with local tips
Insider tip: Bring water shoes, the lake rocks can be a bit rough near the shore, but the swimming is fantastic.
7. The Glacial Retreat – Steps from Nature’s Wonders
This one is for my fellow nature nerds. Tucked just a few minutes walk from the famous Glacial Grooves, The Glacial Retreat feels like a cabin in the woods but with all the comfort you need for a proper recharge. I stayed here during an early fall trip, and the color-changing leaves made the whole property feel enchanted.
The cottage itself has a woodsy vibe with modern upgrades, updated appliances, a fireplace, smart thermostat, but still gives that cozy let’s play board games and sip cocoa energy. It’s also incredibly peaceful. You won’t hear traffic or even much foot traffic, just birds, the occasional owl at night, and the rustle of the tree. It’s a dream for those looking to hike, unplug, and relax.
What makes it special:
- Walking distance to hiking and natural landmarks
- Cozy and quiet with updated amenities
- Feels like a true nature escape
- Great for couples or solo retreats
Insider tip: Pack a journal or a book, this is the kind of place where inspiration strikes. And don’t skip the Glacial Grooves early in the morning; they are eerily beautiful at sunrise.
8. The Garden Grove House ottagecore Dream with Island Charm
Let’s talk vibes. If you are the type who wants to live your best cottagecore life fresh flowers, linen sheets, and vintage decor, The Garden Grove House will steal your heart.
I found this place on a whim when my usual go-to was booked, and honestly, I might never go back. This Airbnb feels like something out of a novel. The hosts keep a real herb garden out front (yes, you can snip basil or mint!), and there’s a swing bench in the yard shaded by wild grape vines.
Inside, it’s airy, eclectic, and filled with thoughtful design touches. The living room has a book nook, the bathroom has a clawfoot tub, and the kitchen has open shelves stacked with handmade pottery. It’s not huge, but it’s incredibly special.
Why it’s a vibe:
- Artistic decor and homegrown herbs
- Quiet, lush yard with gardens and birdsong
- Ideal for couples or creatives needing inspiration
- Excellent host with impeccable taste
Insider tip: Bring a bottle of wine and enjoy a picnic in the garden at dusk. Trust me, it’s as magical as it sounds.
9. The Lighthouse Loft Unique Stay with Island Views
If you are looking for something totally different, the Lighthouse Loft offers a quirky and unforgettable experience. It’s a converted upper-level apartment in a lighthouse-inspired home, and it offers panoramic views of both the lake and forest.
I stayed here last spring, and the moment I walked into the loft, I knew it was something special. Giant windows wrap around the living space, flooding it with light from every angle. There is even a telescope in the corner, which I used every night to stargaze.
It’s a little more modern and minimalist than some of the other rentals, but it’s clean, open, and gives you a sleeping-in-the-sky kind of feeling. Great for a romantic getaway or anyone who wants a unique story to tell.
Why it’s unforgettable:
- 360° panoramic views
- Modern yet cozy layout
- Telescope and star maps included
- Private balcony overlooking the lake
Insider tip: Clear nights on Kelleys Island offer incredible stargazing. Download a stargazing app to fully enjoy the telescope.
10. The East End Escape Budget-Friendly with All the Essentials
Not every getaway needs to be luxurious to be amazing. When I want something simple, affordable, and clean, I turn to the East End Escape. This little Airbnb is tucked near the quieter side of the island and offers a no-frills stay that’s big on value.
It has all the essentials comfortable bed, functional kitchen, hot shower, and even a grill outside. I usually book this one for quick overnight trips when I’m doing photography or fishing on the east shore.
It’s perfect if you’re not planning to hang indoors much and just need a reliable, quiet place to sleep. Despite the lower price tag, it doesn’t feel dingy or bare. The owners clearly care, and it shows in the little touches, clean linens, local maps, and even a cold bottle of water waiting in the fridge.
Best parts:
- Budget-friendly but not basic
- Quiet east side location
- Ideal for solo travelers or quick weekend trips
- Simple and dependable
Insider tip: Check the host’s recommendations they list some lesser-known trails and local eateries most visitors miss.
Final Thoughts: Why Kelleys Island Airbnbs Are the Perfect Escape
If there’s one thing I have learned from hopping around these Kelleys Island Airbnbs, it’s that this place isn’t just a destination, it’s a feeling. It’s waking up to birdsong instead of traffic. It’s watching the sky burst into pinks and oranges over the lake.
It’s sharing stories around a firepit, soaking in silence on a shaded porch, and realizing that sometimes, less really is more. Each Airbnb I stayed in had its own personality, from cozy cottages to lakefront marvels, rustic hideaways to modern gems.
Whether you are planning a romantic weekend, a solo retreat, a family vacation, or a pet-friendly trip, Kelleys Island has an Airbnb with your name written all over it. But more than that? It has the magic of slow moments. And trust me, those are the moments that stick. So go ahead, pick your favorite, pack light, and let the island do the rest. You will be back. I always am.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings