After eating my way through Forsyth, Georgia, I have come to the conclusion that this little town knows how to properly feed its residents. Forsyth’s restaurants offer a wide variety of meals, from fine Southern dishes to mouthwatering barbecue and homemade desserts that taste like they were made by your grandmother. You don’t need to travel to Atlanta or Macon to enjoy delicious food.
So grab a fork (and maybe some stretchy pants), because here are the top 10 Forsyth restaurants, ranked from best to still pretty darn amazing, and why you need to visit them.
1. Grits Café: Modern Southern Magic
If you only have time for one meal in Forsyth, make it Grits Café. This place is the town’s pride and joy a cozy, slightly upscale spot that puts a modern twist on Southern favorites. When I walked in, the warm brick walls and soft lighting made me feel right at home. The servers greeted me like an old friend, and within minutes, my table was filled with comfort food perfection.
Their Shrimp and Grits is hands down the best I have ever had creamy, buttery grits topped with perfectly seasoned shrimp. Pair that with a side of Fried Green Tomatoes and you’ll understand why locals rave about it. Everything here feels intentional, from the fresh ingredients to the attention to detail. Whether it’s date night or Sunday brunch, Grits Café never misses a beat.
Why go: Warm Southern charm, elevated comfort food, and service that makes you feel special.
2. Jonah’s on Johnston: Forsyth’s Seafood Surprise
Who would have thought that Forsyth would have one of Georgia’s greatest seafood restaurants? I was blown away by Jonah’s on Johnston. I could smell the aroma of freshly grilled fish and garlic butter as soon as I walked in, and I knew I was going to love it. Their crab cakes have the perfect amount of spice and are golden and crispy. The Low Country Boil is loaded with perfectly cooked corn, sausage, and shrimp. What about their quiet pups? Risky. You can’t eat just one. The staff is obviously passionate about what they do, and the atmosphere is laid back and family-friendly. It seems as though a restaurant on the beach has been dropped into the middle of Georgia.
Why you should visit: Fresh, flavorful seafood and a laid-back atmosphere that makes every meal feel like a mini vacation.
3. Her Majesty Kitchen: Comfort Food That Rules
When I want pure comfort food, I head to Her Majesty’s Kitchen. It’s a cozy little spot where everything tastes like it was made in your grandmother’s kitchen if your grandma happened to be a Southern cooking queen. Their Chicken and Waffles are sweet, crispy, and buttery in all the right ways. The Country Fried Steak melts in your mouth, and the homemade Peach Cobbler is so good it almost made me tear up. It’s not fancy, but that’s the beauty of it. You walk in hungry and leave happy with a full belly and a warm heart.
A good reason to visit: Big portions, friendly service, and food that feels like home.
4. The Pickled Okra: Farm-to-Table Perfection
The Pickled Okra is the place to go if you enjoy using local, fresh ingredients. Produce and meats from local farms are used to make everything on the menu from scratch. The smoky, tender, and perfectly balanced sweet and savory Smoked Pork Chop with Apple Chutney is an unforgettable dish. The Seasonal Veggie Plate varies based on what’s fresh that week, and their Fried Okra Bites are tasty and crispy. The attention to detail is what I adore most about this place. You can taste the quality in every bite at this type of restaurant.
Why go: Creative, farm-fresh Southern food served with pride and personality.
5. Forsyth Country Cooking: A Local Legend
If you ask any local where to eat, they’ll point you toward Forsyth Country Cooking. This place has been feeding the town for years, and it’s still going strong. The star of the show is their Fried Chicken, crispy, juicy, and seasoned to perfection. Add some Mac and Cheese, Collard Greens, and a fluffy Biscuit, and you have the ultimate Southern comfort meal. It’s an all-you-can-eat buffet, so come hungry. The décor is simple, the people are friendly, and the food is the real deal.
Why go: Home-style Southern food that’s authentic, affordable, and always satisfying.
6. The Whistle Stop Café: A Bit of Movie History
Just a short drive from downtown Forsyth, you’ll find The Whistle Stop Café in Juliette, yes, the same one from the movie Fried Green Tomatoes. It’s as charming in person as it looks on screen. Wooden floors, vintage signs, and the smell of fresh-fried tomatoes fill the air. Of course, the Fried Green Tomatoes are a must, but don’t skip the Pecan Pie or Catfish Sandwich either. Eating here feels like stepping back in time, and the food tastes like the best of Southern nostalgia.
Why go: Iconic setting, classic comfort food, and a touch of Hollywood magic.
7. El Tejado: A Taste of Mexico in Forsyth
El Tejado Mexican Restaurant consistently delivers when you’re craving something a little spicier. The décor is vibrant, the ambiance is lively, and the food is served hot. Their Carne Asada Tacos are bursting with flavor, and their Chicken Fajitas are expertly grilled. The fresh salsa and homemade guacamole are irresistible, and the margaritas? To put it mildly, they don’t hesitate to pour. It’s one of the most enjoyable places to eat in Forsyth because of the friendly and cheerful staff.
Why go: Authentic Mexican food, great vibes, and generous portions
8. JAG’s Pizzeria & Pub: Pizza with Personality
For a casual night out, I love JAG’s Pizzeria & Pub. It’s not your typical chain pizza joint; this one’s local, laid-back, and always packed with regulars. The crust is hand-tossed and perfectly chewy, and the toppings are piled high. My go-to is the Forsyth Special, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, and veggies. Their Buffalo Chicken Pizza also hits the spot, especially with an ice-cold beer. It’s a great place to hang out, watch a game, or bring the family for a fun meal.
Why go: Great pizza, friendly locals, and a relaxed pub vibe.
9. Shane’s Rib Shack: BBQ Heaven
Shane’s Rib Shack is the place to go when you’re craving barbecue. Even before you enter the room, you can smell the aroma of smoked meat. The pulled pork sandwich is served with a tangy, smoky sauce, and the baby back ribs are so delicious that they fall off the bone. Slaw and baked beans complete the ideal Southern dish. It’s casual, reasonably priced, and always delicious.
Why go: Smoky, saucy BBQ that satisfies every time.
10. Scoops Ice Cream: Sweet Endings
Lastly, a visit to Scoops Ice Cream is a must-do for any food tour of Forsyth. It feels like entering a vintage soda shop and is located directly on the town square. You can’t go wrong with anything here, but the Butter Pecan and Georgia Peach Ice Cream are local favorites. It’s the ideal small-town moment, so I always grab a waffle cone and stroll around the square.
Why go: Homemade ice cream, cheerful vibes, and a sweet taste of Forsyth charm.
Why Forsyth’s Food Scene Deserves the Spotlight
The people at Forsyth’s restaurants are just as special as the food. The majority of these establishments are run by families and are based on decades-old recipes and customs. Every plate exudes pride, and as soon as you take a seat, you can feel that warmth.
Despite its small size, Forsyth has a big heart, and you can taste it. Forsyth has what you’re craving, whether it’s peach cobbler, barbecue ribs, or shrimp and grits. Pull off the exit, forego the fast food, and allow Forsyth to demonstrate what true Southern hospitality tastes like the next time you’re traveling down I-75.
FAQs
1. What is the best restaurant in Forsyth for families?
Grits Café and JAG’s Pizzeria & Pub are both great options for families, offering kid-friendly menus, relaxed environments, and plenty of space for everyone.
2. Which Forsyth restaurant is best for a romantic dinner?
Grits Café tops the list for a romantic evening thanks to its cozy ambiance and gourmet Southern dishes. The Pickled Okra also offers an intimate farm-to-table experience.
3. Where can I find the best dessert in Forsyth?
Scoops Ice Cream is unbeatable for classic frozen treats, but don’t miss the peach cobbler at Her Majesty Kitchen it’s legendary among locals.
4. Are there vegetarian-friendly restaurants in Forsyth?
Yes! The Pickled Okra and Grits Café both feature vegetarian-friendly menu options made from fresh, local produce.
5. What makes Forsyth’s dining scene unique?
Forsyth’s restaurants combine small-town hospitality with high-quality cooking. The mix of traditional Southern food, local ingredients, and friendly service gives it a flavor all its own.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings