If there is one place I keep going back to every summer, it’s Kelleys Island. There’s just something magical about this sleepy Lake Erie gem. Picture this: you hop off the ferry, the breeze smells like cedar and lake water, and time instantly slows down. I’ve explored this island inside and out by bike, golf cart, foot, even kayak, and the places I’ve stayed at became a core part of those unforgettable memories.
Whether you’re visiting with your partner, your kids, or your college friends on a nostalgic reunion trip, I’ve personally checked out (and checked into) the best spots around. This isn’t a list of copy-pasted hotel reviews, it is a human experience guide. Let’s get started.
1. Kelleys Island Venture Resort: The Island’s Crown Jewel
Let’s start with the one that consistently performs well. The largest and most comprehensive resort on the island is Kelleys Island Venture Resort.
I have spent two nights here. I went fishing once with a group of friends and once with my wife and children. It was accurate both times. The rooms are not small shoeboxes; they are suites. When you’re traveling with other people, it’s important to have that pleasant distinction between sleeping and relaxing.
The outdoor pool is a favorite of mine. Not Olympic-sized or anything, but perfect for a dip after a day exploring the island. The best part? You’re just a short stroll from downtown and the ferry dock, which means fewer golf cart rentals and more spontaneous ice cream runs.
Highlights:
- Spacious suites with kitchenettes
- Outdoor pool (a rare find on the island)
- Perfect for families, groups, or longer stays
My Tip: Ask for a second-floor room facing the lake. Morning coffee on the balcony hits different.
2. Water’s Edge Retreat: Where Romance Meets Lake Erie
Now, if you are looking for something a little more secluded and romantic, Water’s Edge Retreat is the go-to. This place is for couples, no question. I stayed here for an anniversary trip, and to this day, my wife calls it her favorite vacation spot.
Imagine this: you are soaking in a private hot tub, glass of wine in hand, while the lake glows orange with the sunset. Birds chirp. The breeze rustles through the trees. This isn’t a fantasyits just Tuesday at Water’s Edge.
It’s a small place, so make reservations in advance. The rooms are immaculate and tastefully decorated; there are no dated linens or tacky nautical wallpaper; everything feels carefully chosen and purposeful. Guests have private beach access, so you can swim in the lake without having to share space with other visitors.
Highlights:
- Hot tubs in select rooms
- Unmatched lakefront views
- Quiet, adults-only atmosphere
My Tip: Time your trip for late September, fewer crowds, better prices, and the sunsets are unreal.
3. The Inn on Kelleys Island: Victorian Charm With a Personal Touch
If you’ve ever wished you could stay in a historic lake house with creaky floorboards, floral wallpaper, and an actual front porch swing, this is your spot.
The Inn on Kelleys Island is a restored Victorian home turned cozy B&B. It feels like walking into a Hallmark movie if that movie had amazing blueberry scones every morning.
The shared bathrooms may be a turn-off for some, but don’t let that stop you. The place is impeccably clean, and the common areas encourage socializing with other guests. That’s how I ended up getting great tips on local trails and hidden beaches from a couple I met over breakfast waffles.
Highlights:
- Victorian charm with modern updates
- Amazing hosts (seriously, they are wonderful)
- Great for solo travelers or quiet couples
My Tip: Book a room with lake views it’s worth it. And don’t skip the porch swing. Best spot to read on the island.
4. Eagle’s Nest Inn: A Cozy, Woodland Getaway
Eagles Nest is that place you book when you want to completely unplug. It’s tucked back among trees, far enough from downtown to be quiet, but still just a short bike ride to the action. It’s rustic, sure, but not rough. Think charming cabin rather than bare-bones.
What stood out to me was the breakfast. It’s homemade and hearty, and they accommodate dietary restrictions without making you feel like a bother. I also loved the open lawn where you can sit with a book or binoculars, yes, there are bald eagles here. I spotted one during breakfast once, no joke.
If you are into birdwatching, or just want somewhere peaceful to write in your journal or meditate under a tree, this is it.
Highlights:
- Homemade breakfast (A+)
- Peaceful setting with nature all around
- Popular among nature lovers and birdwatchers
My Tip: Bring bug spray. It’s the woods, after all. Also, take the trail nearby that leads to the north shore, it’s a short, beautiful walk.
5. House on Huntington Lane B&B: Where Time Slows Down
This one’s special. House on Huntington Lane is over 100 years old, but it doesn’t feel old in the bad way. Instead, it has that timeless comfort like staying at your cool aunt’s countryside home.
It’s set a bit off the main roads, so you really feel like you’re tucked away. You will hear crickets at night and birds in the morning. The rooms are quaint and simple, nothing fancy, but they have this undeniable warmth.
There is something deeply grounding about staying here. I remember sipping tea on the front porch, the whole world quiet, just soaking in that island energy. It’s a place that reminds you to breathe deeper and slow down.
Highlights:
- Serene, off-the-beaten-path location
- Historic character with personal charm
- Great for digital detox weekends
My Tip: Disconnect from Wi-Fi for at least a day here. You will come back feeling better than after a spa day.
6. House on the Lake: A Private Slice of Paradise
This place is all about the view. I mean it when you open the curtains in the morning and see the sun sparkling on Lake Erie, you will understand why I call this one a hidden gem.
House on the Lake is exactly what it sounds like: a charming home nestled right on the shoreline with private waterfront access. I stayed here with a couple of close friends, and we spent most of our time on the deck coffee in the morning, wine at sunset, and stargazing at night. It’s tucked into the woods, so you get that rare combo of water and forest.
The inside is rustic but thoughtfully done, with comfy furniture, modern appliances, and plenty of room for a family or group. But really, it’s the setting that steals the show. Total peace and privacy.
Highlights:
- Private lake access
- Spacious deck with incredible views
- Forested surroundings for added privacy
My Tip: Bring a good book and a blanket. This deck is made for afternoon naps with a breeze off the lake.
7. The Quarry Vista Home: Spa Luxury Meets Island Chill
This is one of the most upscale stays on Kelleys Island, and yes, it’s worth every penny. I stayed at the Quarry Vista Home for a milestone birthday, and it felt like living in a lakefront spa for the weekend.
This three-bedroom stunner has it all: a private hot tub, wraparound deck, fully modern kitchen, and an incredible view of the old quarry. It’s not right on the lake, but you won’t miss it. The outdoor area is landscaped beautifully, and there’s plenty of space for grilling, lounging, or hot tubbing under the stars.
The inside? Gorgeous. We are talking sleek counters, plush furniture, and those soft fluffy robes you never want to take off. It’s a little slice of modern luxury in the middle of nature.
Highlights:
- Hot tub and spa-style bathrooms
- Ideal for special occasions or splurges
- Luxury living with island soul
My Tip: Book this one in shoulder season (May or September) for the best rates and total tranquility. It’s perfect for relaxing before the busy summer crowds hit.
8. Lake Point Motel: A Budget-Friendly Favorite with Big Charm
Alright, let’s talk budget. Not every trip needs a hot tub or a fancy suite sometimes you just want a clean, comfy room, a hot shower, and easy access to the beach. That’s where Lake Point Motel shines.
I stayed here once when everything else on the island was booked, and I’m so glad I did. It’s small, family-run, and super welcoming. There’s a community vibe, people chatting over morning coffee, grilling out together, kids playing in the yard. It felt like summer camp for grown-ups (in the best way).
The rooms are basic but clean, and there’s a pebble beach just steps away. At night, you can sit around the fire pit, toast some marshmallows, and make new friends.
- Affordable pricing
- Firepit and beach access
- Great for families or solo travelers
My Tip: Pack a cooler and use the grill area, it’s a great way to save money and enjoy the outdoors.
9. Cedar Point Marina Hotel Breakers (Off-Island Bonus Pick)
Okay, hear me out technically, this one’s across the water, but if you are doing a split trip between Cedar Point and Kelleys Island, Hotel Breakers is a luxurious and incredibly convenient option. We stayed here before heading to the island, and it felt like easing into the vacation with a bit of pampering first.
This place is a full-blown resort, with pools, a private beach, restaurants, and even early entry to the theme park.
It’s more fast-paced than the island itself, but that’s part of the charm. Families especially love it for the convenience, but even as a couple, we found ourselves relaxing in the poolside cabanas with drinks in hand, grateful for a good night’s sleep before catching the ferry.
Highlights:
- Resort-level amenities
- Pool, beach, bars, restaurants on-site
- Great starting or ending point for your island trip
My Tip: Book a lake-view room. And if you are traveling with kids, use the early park access, it’s a lifesaver for beating lines.
10. Caddy Shack Square Lodging: Stay Where the Action Is
Let’s shift gears for a moment. What if you’re looking to be in the middle of everything? Where can you walk out your door and grab a burger, ice cream, or a cocktail without even thinking twice? Enter: Caddy Shack Square Lodging. I stayed here with a group of college friends for a birthday weekend, and it was the most fun I have had on the island in a while.
You are steps from the island’s liveliest attractions, mini-golf, bars, shops, food trucks, you name it. It’s not quiet, but it is incredibly convenient. The rooms are modest but clean, and the vibe is social. This is where you stay if your trip is more about laughs, late-night drinks, and making memories than peace and quiet.
Highlights:
- Located in the heart of the island’s nightlife
- Perfect for groups and friend trips
- Steps from restaurants, bars, and attractions
My Tip: Bring earplugs if you are a light sleeper. But honestly, chances are you will be out late too, so you might not even need them.
11. Camp Patmos Guest Cabins (Faith-Based Family Stay)
Lastly, let’s talk about something a little different:. Known mainly as a Christian youth camp, this beautiful lakeside property also offers guest cabins during select times of the season, typically spring and fall.
These cabins are simple and affordable, but the views and setting are incredible. You are surrounded by nature, the stars are next-level clear at night, and there is a beautiful spiritual energy that just makes you feel lighter.
I stayed here once during a small retreat weekend, and it was truly restorative.
While it’s more niche (and doesn’t have all the amenities of a hotel), it’s absolutely worth considering if you are looking for a retreat-like experience that aligns with your faith or if you just want a quiet, budget-friendly stay in a peaceful environment.
Highlights:
- Beautiful setting with spiritual retreat vibes
- Affordable and serene
- Great for families or faith-based groups
My Tip: Contact them directly to check availability outside of the youth camp season. It’s limited but totally worth it.
My Final Thoughts
No matter your flavor of escape, whether you’re craving sunset views from a hot tub, a historic stay with personality, or a roomy family retreat with all the trimmings, Kelleys Island has a spot that fits. I’ve sat watching the waves at Water’s Edge, enjoyed lazy mornings at Venture Resort, and strolled the trails near the B&Bs. Each stay has left a vivid, warm memory.
Let me know if you want personal tips on dining, ferry logistics, or which room I’d grab if I went back next month. I have got stories and maybe a few insider seat-of-my-pants recommendations for seafood, evening strolls, or where to catch those unbeatable island sunrises.
You may also like to read about: Top 6 Kelleys Island Hotels with a Pool, Top 10 Kelleys Island Airbnbs
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings