There is something magical about Kelleys Islands’ fresh lake breezes, charming streets, and that laid-back pace that makes you forget the rest of the world. But here’s the thing: after a day of biking the trails, exploring limestone cliffs, or sipping wine at a local vineyard, nothing beats slipping into a cool pool.
Trust me, I’ve spent enough sunny afternoons here to know that the right hotel pool can turn a good trip into a perfect one. So, I have rounded up my favorite Kelleys Island stays with pools, each with its own personality, charm, and a splash of something special. Let’s dive in.
1. Kelleys Island Venture Resort The Classic Island Escape
Staying here feels like discovering a secret treasure on Lake Erie. I have lounged by that gorgeous seasonal outdoor pool, complete with loungers, umbrellas, and a bubbling hot tub framed by a charming rock garden and waterfall, pure magic on a sunny afternoon.
The suites upstairs even offer loft sleeping spaces and views of both the pool and lake through dormer windows, perfect for drifting off while waves whisper outside. The pool deck? Reserved strictly for guests and wristbands issued at check-in keep it exclusive and relaxing.
Guests rave about the resort’s walkable proximity to downtown and island gems like local shops and dining at Kelleys Island Venture Resort. I still remember starting my day with coffee on that multi-tiered deck, watching boats drift by, it’s one of those moments that feels timeless.
2. Hotel Breakers at Cedar Point
Hotel Breakers, located in Sandusky, is my pick for families or thrill-seekers combining a Kelleys Island visit with Cedar Point’s roller coasters. I stayed here during a summer trip, and the outdoor pool area, with its vibrant energy and lake views, was a highlight. Kids splashed in the shallow end while I relaxed with a coffee from the on-site Starbucks.
The hotel’s classic charm, combined with modern amenities like spacious rooms and free Wi-Fi, makes it a solid choice. The 20-minute ferry ride to Kelleys Island is a breeze, and you can’t beat the convenience of free parking for day trips.
3. Bayshore Resort
Bayshore Resort in Put-in-Bay is perfect for those craving a social scene. I visited with friends for a weekend getaway, and the pool’s swim-up bar was the heart of our stay, think tropical drinks and new friends under the sun. The resort’s waterfront location offers stunning views of Lake Erie, and the rooms are bright and comfortable, with balconies that let you soak in the harbor’s energy.
It’s a quick ferry ride to Kelleys Island for a quieter day trip, balancing Put-in-Bay’s party vibe with Kelleys’ calm. Note that weekends can get lively, so plan accordingly if you prefer peace.
4. Lakeside’s Historic Hotel Lakeside
Hotel Lakeside, in the gated Lakeside community near Marblehead, is a charming retreat I discovered during a family reunion. The seasonal community pool is a hit with kids, and I loved the shaded lounge chairs where I could sip lemonade while watching the little ones play.
The hotel’s Victorian vibe, with cozy rooms and a welcoming dining hall, feels like stepping back in time. The nearby ferry to Kelleys Island makes it easy to visit for a day of beachcombing or exploring the island’s winery. The gated community requires a day pass, but it’s worth it for the serene setting.
5. Great Wolf Lodge
Great Wolf Lodge is a kids’ paradise and a parents’ dream. I took my niece and nephews here last winter, and the indoor water park kept them entertained for hours with slides and splash zones. In summer, the outdoor pool is a sunny delight, perfect for relaxing after a ferry trip to Kelleys Island.
The lodge’s themed rooms, with bunk beds for kids, were a hit, and the on-site dining options meant we never had to leave. It’s a bit pricier, but the all-in-one experience makes it worthwhile for families.
6. Holiday Inn Express Suites Port Clinton
During a solo trip last fall, I stayed at the Holiday Inn Express Suites in Port Clinton and was impressed by its clean, modern vibe and indoor pool. After a chilly day exploring Kelleys Islands’ North Pond Nature Preserve, the heated pool was a cozy retreat.
The complimentary breakfast buffet, with its hot cinnamon rolls, was a morning highlight, and the hotel’s proximity to the Jet Express ferry made island visits effortless. The staff’s local recommendations, like dining at Catawba Inn, added a personal touch to my stay.
Why a Pool Makes Your Kelleys Island Trip Unforgettable
A pool isn’t just a perk, it’s a game-changer. After kayaking along the island’s shores or biking to Long Point Preserve, a refreshing swim feels like a reward. Pools also create memories, whether it’s kids giggling in the shallow end or couples sharing a quiet moment under the stars.
My time on Kelleys Island has shown me that the right hotel can elevate your trip, and these properties deliver comfort, convenience, and a splash of fun.
Wrapping Up
Kelleys Island is a slice of Lake Erie magic, and these hotels with pools make it even more inviting. From the intimate luxury of Kelleys Island Venture Resort to the family frenzy of Great Wolf Lodge, there’s a perfect spot for every traveler.
Having experienced these places firsthand or vetted them thoroughly, I’m confident they will make your trip unforgettable. Which hotel is calling your name?
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings